Entrepreneurial spirit needs to resurface to save Tahoe
By Garry Bowen
Back in the day, when Harveys was the Wagon Wheel with Food, Fun & Fortune as a slogan, we locals used to kid each other that Tahoe’s business climate was conducted in only one of two ways, depending on the time of year: fast or half-fast.
In the time since, we seem to have sacrificed the former and settled for a constant pattern of the latter.
It may now be useful to offer a particular vantage point of what our joking actually meant to the South Shore. As the original Harveys was “one-stop” (a cold beer, a hand of blackjack, a period of time at a one-armed bandit, a sandwich, or a tank of gas) when it started in 1944, it had few employees – and they all had to wear several hats throughout their workday. At the time, everyone was able to pour you a beer, deal you a hand of cards, be a croupier, or run outside and pump the gas necessary to go back down to California. The only real remnant of that day and age is the Sage Room, as that area remains in pretty much the same place as then, even after the rebuilding (the ’80 bomb blast), the remodeling, the additions, and the changes in ownership.
Later in the ’50s, as Stateline grew, Shehadi’s was across the street to be bought by Harrah’s and George’s Gateway Club was on the corner of Stateline Avenue. That became Harrah’s Lake Club after Bill Harrah bought both, and the interior of the Lake Club harbored the original South Shore Room, ostensibly while the location we now know was being built, being opened in 1959. Sen. George Cannon of Reno’s Cannon Airport fame was the Gateway Club’s original proprietor, with the Cal-Va-Rado coffee shop across the street in California from the Lake Club coffee shop. Two ’50s-style sit-down coffee shops, imagine that.
About the same period of time, the “originals” of Heavenly (Valley), Rudy Gersich, Curly Musso, Chris Kuraisa, later Hugh Killebrew (as their attorney) brought in Dave Gay (Gay Propane) to develop the tramway, which opened in 1962. This was the era of Koflach leather ski boots, secured to skis with long-thong leather bindings, and long, skinny skis seemingly made out of barrel staves, soon to see drastic changes in ski technology. For example, with the introduction in 1965 of the Lange poured-plastic aluminum-buckled ski boot, “space-age” in its day, the skiing industry came into its own.
Setting that stage, it is important to note that the South Shore Room, heralding the big entertainer era, was actually opened before the Squaw Valley Olympics (1960), meaning that both the tramway and the South Shore Room were strong evidence of vision, decisiveness, and a level of entrepreneurial skill we really haven’t seen since. Even the Lake Tahoe Airport was an exercise in entrepreneurial courage.
After Squaw Valley, with its first globally-televised entrée of the Lake Tahoe region into the national and international psyche, was crowned a success, and the South Shore was picking up steam. Bill Harrah was intrigued by the international exposure, and being the man that he was, began looking at how to tap into the now worldwide exposure that only Olympic events can secure. His answer was to think about extending the runway at the airport to accommodate planes large enough, and with enough range, to entice an international clientele. This would require large commercial jets, and soon the Harrah’s Starliner was born – with the familiar and graceful “swoop” underneath the Harrah’s logo that exists to this day, he instead used a number of stars following the same gentle arc on the side of the Starliner. With both the airport and the proper sized plane in place, he embarked upon the now-obscure junkets direct from our now-moribund airport to Mexico City, where folks from Caracas, Buenos Aires, and elsewhere, joined those already assembled in Mexico City to fly directly into the Lake Tahoe Airport.
From a gaming perspective, this added a particularly elegant spin to the Tahoe South Shore experience, coinciding as it did with the introduction of baccarat, a simple and cosmopolitan game of high dollar fame. It appears that its introduction was thought to be more of an attraction to the sophisticated upper-end clientele of European descent, and as a baccarat dealer had to speak at least three languages (ala Europe and South America), they were also dressed elegantly: black tie, cummerbund, and dinner jacket.
As baccarat is traditionally played only with cash (no chips), and is played relatively fast – it is only you against either the player or the dealer, with a high count of 9 (face cards are counted as zero), their floor-to-ceiling glass enclosures were a sight to behold, as real money changed hands, sometimes in amazing amounts.
This in turn compounded the “dinner show” experience, also similarly (but not quite) dressed up, as baccarat enclosures were alongside the entrance to the South Shore Room – creating a special Tahoe cachet. This, combined with the more egalitarian “nickel player” and Oriental keno players, assured that all the “sales per square foot” aspects were covered across the entire casino floor, with food and beverage to match.
Ironically, after Bill Harrah died, and the Harrah’s enterprise changed hands, the focus was lost, as it changed to more of a bottom-line emphasis, as the business model success that Harrah achieved with his comprehensive innovations became a convenient source for corporate bean counters to cut.
One glaring example concerned the now-successful Embassy Suites next door – it replaced a large valet parking lot that spanned the space between Harrah’s and the now-gone 600 room Tahoe Inn. As Harrah’s was purchased by Holiday Inn, the hotel mentality took over, as the large prominent space looked pretty inviting to develop. Only problem was the existing valet parking lot was generating more cash flow for Harrah’s than could any hotel/motel property due to the fact that, in a location like Tahoe, reliant as it is on Highway 50 and ’50s era car travel (still), cars were pulling into Harrah’s even before they were even in Nevada, and the parking lot spaces could be filled with new customers on an ongoing basis, around the clock. The 500-car valet parking lot was turned over five or six times in 24 hours versus a 400-room Embassy Suites having each room turn over but once – regardless of full occupancy. That parking lot also did not have a capital expense of over $100 million, while at the same time diluting Harrah’s traffic flow, thereby its revenue stream. Harrah’s lost significant ground – literally.
A valet parking lot may not seem to be an important business element, but “Attendant” parking was a stand-alone department for Bill Harrah, but was soon subsumed into just another hotel function for a hotelier — a mere channel into a room check-in. The difference in emphasis is profound, as the efficiency of that department resulted in yet another synergistic compounding of the business innovations already mentioned for Harrah, and resulted in their ongoing Stateline prominence over Harvey’s, Sierra Tahoe, and Caesars.
In this milieu, the weather was also a business consideration, which is easiest described as “make hay while the sun shines”. As provincial as that now seems (almost quaint), it was nevertheless a serious factor.
Coming out of the ’40s and ’50s, the highways openings and closings were not as reliable, in that Highway 50 was closed a lot more during winter. This created an atmosphere that cultivated the idea of doing as much business as you could during the emerging spring, as much as possible during summer, and the nurture of another market descending into fall. Winter would then take care of itself, with one exception: if your business employed people with families, rent and mortgages to pay, food and clothing to buy, then you had better have some customers whether it was day, swing or graveyard. The answer was to have, only in late fall into emerging spring, a “leave-the-driving-to-us” (thanks Greyhound) marketing campaign to bus-in supplemental clientele, shoring up what Bill Cosby, Glen Campbell, Sammy Davis Jr. and Ann-Margret drew in the ever-busy summers. Current corporate management’s only emphasis is to insist that the “shoulder season” should be as lucrative as summer, even though they were chipping away at their own “making hay” by canceling big entertainment, and not fully understanding what they had in the first place. Flattening out your revenue streams is obviously not the answer, and will not ever be.
Slow-forward to now (emblematic of a serious decline) and realize that such business models are no more, now combined as they are with the “picture-postcard mentality” inherent to a second/third home real estate emphasis, and the need for a serious reinvention of South Shore economy is much easier to perceive.
Couple this with a serious lack of negotiating skills (for insight, the word business in Spanish is negotio) it becomes much clearer why progress is seriously undermined with our now-infamous “Ta-hole”, our transit system going bankrupt with an over $2 million deficit (in spite of having a dozen-member board), and now the ridiculous contractual discussions shutting down our gateway project at El Dorado Beach.
This long look-back is timed with the “au currant” popularity of the soon-to be-done Prosperity Plan, as Tahoe will need to extend its perspective with a foundation of understanding what Tahoe has been to its constituents (whether they live or just visit). It has the deep “carriage-trade” roots of other eras, a history of profound entrepreneurial innovation, and magnificent natural beauty, all very transferable into new sustainable economic development, but not if it thinks in continued terms of ‘half-fast’.
To restore our confidence in ourselves requires a nostalgic appreciation way beyond such environmental symbiotic relationships like those of the TRPA and “Keep Tahoe Blue”. We don’t need to be “fast” and certainly not “half-fast”. We need to “get real” real fast.
Garry Bowen has a 50-year connection to the South Shore, with an immediate past devoted to global sustainability, on most of its current fronts: green building, energy and water efficiencies, and public health. He’s also in the process of planning with his classmates their 50-year South Tahoe High reunion. He may be reached at tahoefuture@gmail.com or (775) 690.6900.
An interesting bit of history…and a whole lot of truth about this town, where I have lived for 38 years…and vacationed here much before I moved here. I definitely concur about Harrah’s, and the bean counters. I remember the old airport…off Kahle Drive at the Highway….and all the snow that fell in a short time in January 1952, and essentially shut down the town.
As for the future of this town….I am not overly optimistic.
Lets not live in the past, that is a big part of our problem. The old Tahoe is gone never to return. The sooner we realize this the better off we will be.
The city better batton down the hatches even more. The economy is soon to take another dive downward whether you want to believe it or not.
Nice bit of history, thank you (though I’m sure you meant Sahara Tahoe when you wrote “Sierra Tahoe”). Appreciated the look into the story of our town. I’ve said for long the “bean counter” attitude of the corporations that now own the gaming institutions is the cause of their demise. Bill Harrah wanted profits, of course, but he wasn’t afraid to spend money to make money. The long ago attitude of “keep food and entertainment costs low, we’ll get it at the machines and tables” are gone (and so are the droves of guests).
I don’t think the writer is talking about going back, just look at what we did to create ourselves and take on that spirit for invention again. We can’t go forward with thinking what we’re doing is right, we need to change, and continue to change, to be the community we want to be. We need tourists to succeed, but they won’t come when they can find what they want elsewhere, and cheaper and friendlier.
So, what do we do? We know what needs to be done (we’ve talked the subject gazillions of times) but we can’t wait for someone else to do it….we need those with the entrepreneurial spirit to lead the way today.
So Robert, how will this dive affect the real estate market?
From the author:
The gentleman is correct that it was indeed “Sahara Tahoe”;I know of the winter of ’52, but would also use as a ‘hardship’ reference point the more recent winter of 68/69, with a snowpack of 599″ as of January 1st: 1″ shy of 50’…
In answer to the question posed of Mr. Stiles, whose cryptic comment about a further real estate dive triggered it, he may want to answer that himself, but he may be referring to the fact that the national commercial real estate market is in many ways in much worse condition than even the residential, as the dollar amounts are proportionately way higher than the individual home, and no one seems willing to acknowledge it.
In South Lake Tahoe, the commercial vacancy rate is way above 30%, so creativity and innovation are probably the order of the day.
Relating to “economic justice”, I am always reminded that a person’s experience is largely determined by where they fit “on the food chain” in the workplace, and in the financial and social systems. Like the old story about the blindfolded person’s describing of an elephant in the room (it’s a ‘metaphor’ …) – their description and experience is dependent on which part of the elephant they are in contact with.
I can appreciate a fondness for “glory days” when everything was growing or being built, and even a belief that a return to that mentality will save a current economic down turn. There are two other major pieces in play that affect the future as it goes forward: 1- the development, both economic and physical of SLT followed a similar pattern of irresponsible capitalism and environmental wrecklessness as the rest of the country in a post WW2 United States. 2- Is the approach, economic/environmental used in the last 50 years appropriate for the upcoming 50?
My personal opinion is no. The endless consumption of capitalist city/machine only leaves waste in it’s path and Tahoe is far too valuable for the economic model as Las Vegas. I would look to Lake towns in Europe like Como (Italy), or Interlaken (Switzerland) where the commerce has reached a balance and harmony with the environment it exists within.
I would look to Lake towns in Europe like Como (Italy), or Interleukin (Switzerland) where the commerce has reached a balance and harmony with the environment it exists within.
WILLIAM, THEY DIDN’T HAVE A TRPA TO HAVE TO CONTEND WITH,IT’S A WHOLE DIFFERENT ANIMAL HERE.
The endless consumption of capitalist city/machine only leaves waste in it’s path.
I WILL TOTAL AGREE ON THIS,BUT THIS CITY HAS TOO MANY SPOONS STIRRING THE POT TO HAVE ANY REAL GOOD QUAILTY “TASTE EMEREGE’…THEY KNOW WHAT THEY WANT, BUT NEVER AGREE ON HOW GET THERE.
30 YEAR HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD WITH THIS COMMENT”
We need tourists to succeed, but they won’t come when they can find what they want elsewhere, and cheaper and friendlier.
That comment sums up what Indian gaming learned,they now have lots power,cash, to keep right on counting the money and they don’t need times shares nor lake,nor skiing outdoor activities, to succeed making countless millions, while dumb azz whites “Fight” over what part the pie do they get.
“mah-zen”-shan” ……means money .
People in Tahoe don’t know the wisdom of sharing…the Native Americans stayed alive with this simple philosophy, why can’t this city take a pointer to Success?
Again from the Author:
Good to see that the juices are flowing out there in response:
Any comments about ‘living in the past’ completely miss the point – with reference to the last two paragraphs,we simply need to keep in mind the “deep carriage-trade roots of other eras, a history of profound entrepreneurial innovation, and magnificent natural beauty, all very transferable into new sustainable economic development”, as it is now possible to use the now ‘raw material’ of a ‘blighted’ town (both physically and mentally) to surpass any of the Alpine areas mentioned with a new and contemporary paradigm. We owe it to ouselves.
I have for years advocated “policies equal to the scenery”, which does not necessarily include the now-prevalent stand-off political positions, once the beauty and symmetry of global sustainability are realized, engaged and implemented.
This would be a “top line” for the Lake Tahoe Basin, which of course begins and ends with its’ beauty.
As to its’ “bottom line”, once it is learned that all parameters (for TRPA, their thresholds) can be more than satisfied, absent the ‘heartburn’ of having to consider additional expense, it will be refreshing to find out how much money needn’t be ‘left on the table’ thru so many ill-advised “throughputs”. . .
Finally, another implied point is with regards to gaming(or, to be more euphemistic,’entertainment’)- I would remind you all that it is a service industry, and as such is absent serious ‘smoke-stack’ issues to deal with, meaning all that’s necessary are substantial shifts in mind set and organizational development.
This realization, if taken seriously, can and should allow us to “get real, real fast” in shedding residual “half-fast” thinking and start moving in a direction we all realistically hope for.
In short, all the elements for success are already here, and always have been . . .