Opinion: Obituaries should be treated with reverence
By Kathryn Reed
Obituaries are big business. A year ago, my mom spent more than $2,000 to place my dad’s obit in three publications.
It was free on Lake Tahoe News. It’s free to everyone, not just to my relatives.
I say this on the one-year anniversary of my dad’s death to make the point that I find it shameful newspapers charge for obituaries – in print or online. It’s almost inhumane.
Yes, I understand as well as anyone that a publication is a business. But I also understand that every life is a story.
No one charges a public agency for coverage of its meetings. No one pays to get a feature story written. A community announcement doesn’t cost money.
Why, then, charge for an obituary? Does it really take up space that is better used for some other editorial space?
My answer is an emphatic no.
And why treat it like an ad? That really is treating the deceased with disrespect.
Nancy Hayden Oliver, who I worked with at the Tahoe Daily Tribune twice, taught me a few things when I was her boss. I learned the importance of letting people tell the story of the deceased person through the obituary. She convinced me it’s OK in that circumstance to use first names on second reference – instead of last name, as is customary in news stories.
She taught me that if there is a typo, you run it again. You fix it until it’s correct. You only die once. It’s imperative the accuracy of the obit live on factually.
I can’t count the times I’ve spoken to the families left behind. It’s amazing how the simplest of facts escape their memory. It’s amazing how the person’s life story flows like a novel.
I laugh. I cry. But mostly I listen.
I don’t like writing obituaries. I feel guilty I have waited to know this person after I’m unable to speak to them. I feel a much different loss than the family – the loss of never knowing that person.
But those are actually the easier obits to write. It’s when I know the person or the family that I have the hardest time holding it together. It’s been even harder this last year. We’re in this club together of having lost someone so incredibly important to us. Each death brings up my own sadness.
Death isn’t easy. No one teaches us how to deal with it. We aren’t supposed to talk about it. But it’s real.
And it is so incredibly important how what could be the last (as well as first) thing published about that person be treated. The words about someone who has died deserve to be treated with respect and published in a manner that shows dignity.
When I worked for papers like the San Francisco Chronicle and Las Vegas Sun, obits about well-known people were written ahead of time. This means all that has to be inserted are the date of death, services, and a quote from someone. It may sound morbid, but it speeds up the process of getting the news out to the public.
I’ve thought about doing that for some people in the Lake Tahoe Basin and beyond – because, really, you could get that person’s input. Yes, morbid, but let me tell you, I would rather write my obit than leave it to my grieving family. I know how hard it was for my three sisters, my mom, my aunt and I to massage my dad’s obit. As an engineer, he probably would have it whittled to five paragraphs that cost a fraction of what mom paid.
Still, though, one point of this is to have you think about what you would want said about you. And then, if you think you will be the provider of information for an obit for someone, get the information out of him or her now. One day it may be too late.
Well said! We thank you for your kindness.
Great piece Kae; thanks. I read that Elizabeth Taylor’s obit was written years ago and the man who wrote it died before she did. I’ve decided I’ll let others write about how they want to remember me. I’ll be dead and won’t really care!
Very well put Kae.
Nice article Kae.
AMEN Kae
Nice article Kay. I totally agree with you. When Heide’s dad passed away I was sickened at the “strictly business” attitude of the Tribune. I agree that one shouldn’t have to pay for an obituary. And then to have it treated as a typical ad, where what size you get depends on how much you can afford, is reprehensible. Grieving families shouldn’t have to struggle with, “can we afford a quarter page to honor dear old dad?”. And then, to add insult to injury, there seems to be no reverence on the placement of the obituary, as it is simply lumped into the various ads of local businesses. I mean, really, an obituary placed next to an add for a party at a local casino bar or a place to buy lingerie? I really like your idea of writing your own obituary ahead of time. I think I will do that. Peace to you today on the anniversary of your dad’s passing.
I’m “into” genealogy and obits are SO important to help find ancestors.. name as many family members as possible.. print important dates.. giving cause helps family watch for signs of illness! Where did they come from? Where did they grow up? All helpful information!
Couldn’t have said it better myself, Kae! It is a sad affair that many businesses will take advantage of grieving people. I watched a mortuary really work my Grandmother over when she was making funeral arrangements for my Grandfather…shameful!
Great job Kae. It made me cry. love you, PAM
Great article Kae and my thoughts are with you on the anniversary of our Dad’s death.
Well put. Thanks for pointing this out to us. I am sure your dad would be proud of your input. We recently lost a brother who used to live here and never had an obit for him. Now that i realize that it is free on LT NEWS i owe him this. Thanks for the advice.
Good article, great opinion, and helpful advice Kae. I was very fortunate to place one free obituary for my mother and father in their local paper – it was very difficult to condense a life story (per se) to just a few paragraphs.
Great perspective and right on the money. As the writer in my family, I’m the obit incumbent. Sadly, the number I’ve composed has increased over the years. It does, however, provide unique insight to the family history and dynamic, which I’ve come to appreciate. There’s also a simultaneous sense of loss/regret, as you characterized, in that it took a death to approach knowing those inner-most layers of the person. I’ve come away convinced that sharing those deep places within yourself, or finally telling the stories you always said you would some day, with those most important to you – while still alive – will only serve to strengthen family relationships and foster a lasting legacy …
Great article. Even more disturbing is that in the SJ Merc obits (and I am sure it is happening in major papers everywhere) the funeral homes are branding the obits (that the families have paid for)! At the bottom of more that 2/3 of each obit is the logo for the funeral home or cemetery. I have already told my family NO WAY. I find this disgusting at the least.
We used McFarlane Mortuary and were given free access to McFarlaneMortuary.com…
Very exciting we put up what we wanted… Written material, Pictures, and even videos with no charge and we had complete control of the content. Our friends could leave comments etc. Just wonderful.
Interesting and factual, especilaly now that i am in my 85 year. So far it has been a heck of a ride.
My rudest awakening was brought about
by serving on the 92/93 El Dorado County grand jury. Factual information discussed
during the Grand Jurors Association meetings added too the awakening.
The information i am refering too was not secret,it was not allowed to be published.
On occasion,i did receive secret grand jury info in the mail. That info went too good cause.
Think i will write my obit for my kids grandkids and greatgrand kids.
Kae,
I know I was in your thoughts in this article as were many others. Thank you again for letting me know in advance that the Trib would charge me for Mike’s obituary, so that it didn’t come as such a shock. The article was poignant as this is such a hard subject to approach. Thank you again for your help. Thinking of you and your Dad.
Excellent article…brought tears to my eyes. Many of us locally have talked about how disgusting it is that the Tribune charges for obituaries. It didn’t used to be like that. Maybe that’s why that paper is going downhill fast!
Kae, This is one of many reasons to read the Lake Tahoe News, thanks for the article.