South Shore fighting Caltrans’ Echo Summit closure date
By Kathryn Reed
South Shore officials are fighting Caltrans’ decision to close Echo Summit four days before the largest professional cycling event in North America starts in Stateline.
State Sen. Ted Gaines, R-Roseville, has stepped into the fray – again. He has arranged for a conference call for Monday with local officials and Caltrans District 3 Director Jody Jones.
“Shock is the word being used. This totally caught people by surprise. There wasn’t even a phone call. Just a press release went out and that’s that,” said Steve Teshara, chairman of the South Shore Transportation Management Association.
This agency that has been in existence since 1994 is taking the lead on changing the start date for the closure. Teshara said anytime after May 15 would be acceptable.
The California Department of Transportation announced April 29 that starting May 11 Highway 50 over Echo Summit would be closed for two weeks to replace the dilapidated rock wall. This route is the main artery between the South Shore and points west.
With about 35,000 spectators expected at the start for the Amgen Tour de California, many would presumably be coming over Echo Summit.
Although there are alternative routes to get to South Lake Tahoe, what has South Shore tourism officials worried is people will skip their end of the lake and instead opt to be on the North Shore. Northstar is where the first leg ends and Squaw Valley is where Day 2 starts.
While the Echo Summit project has been talked about for years and for more than a month people knew it could start any time after May 1, Caltrans gave no reason why May 11 was picked.
Caltrans officials were not available for comment Friday.
The criteria had been the need for a window of 10 straight days of clear weather. The contractor also faces penalties if the full closure extends into June. Plus, the road will be open during Memorial Day weekend.
May is traditionally an iffy weather month in Lake Tahoe, with 2010 full of snowy days.
Tourism officials have already had to deflect misinformation that has been published. The May-June issue of Via magazine wrongly stated Echo Summit would be closed through June. The reality is after the two week closure, it will be subject to controlled traffic for up to six weeks. Construction will end at noon on Fridays and the road completely open Memorial Day — and if work is still going on, Fourth of July.
“With respect to this project, the community has been continuously misled. They said they understood how important Amgen is and it doesn’t seem important at all,” Teshara said of Caltrans.
Teshara once was an advocate for the Echo Summit project starting in May. He wrote a letter to Caltrans saying as much. But this was before the region knew it would be hosting multiple stages of the bike race.
At a March 9 meeting with Gaines, Caltrans, Sierra-at-Tahoe General Manager John Rice, Andrew Strain of Heavenly Mountain Resort, B Gorman with Lake Tahoe South Shore Chamber of Commerce, reps from contractor C.C. Myers, South Tahoe Councilman Tom Davis, and South Tahoe staff member Nancy Kerry, it was revealed Caltrans picked May based on Teshara’s letter. They thought he was speaking for the basin, even though at the time he was speaking on behalf of the North Shore – which is a likely beneficiary of an Echo Summit closure.
Caltrans, according to people at the meeting, did not ask for other input. But Amgen announced in February how the Tahoe area would be part of this year’s race, so Caltrans has had time to adjust any internal time line it may have had.
While May is a traditionally slow time throughout the Lake Tahoe Basin, it has been well documented events literally drive people to the basin. That was an impetus for striving to be part of Tour de California.
What worries South Shore officials is Caltrans’ decision to close Echo Summit pre-Amgen will drive them elsewhere.
“Shock is the word being used. This totally caught people by surprise. There wasn’t even a phone call. Just a press release went out and that’s that…” This statement is absolutely false, this has been discussed for two years. We all knew it was coming. The planning of the Amgen bike race was irresponsible as regards this project. It was a known issue, everyone knew it was coming. Last moment surprise is incredibly selfish and irresponsible. God knows, we don’t like Caltrans’ arrogance but in this case, there was plenty of warning that Highway 50 would be limited and/or closed during this time frame.
I agree with dumbfounded. This has not been kept as any kind of secret from everyone. The work needs to be done. To try to stop the work or delay it is irresponsible. What if the whole retaining wall were to drop off the side of the cliff and the road was gone? Then our precious visitors couldn’t have an easy drive to South Lake for who knows how long.
The LTVA shouldn’t of pushed for this race to come to Tahoe with the knowledge of this impending work. They should have waited till next year when we will have a beautiful new section of road for the people coming to drive down. Hopefully their decision doesn’t taint Tahoe for people organizing the tour and they return next year.
They have already decided to go elsewhere next year.
I was always led to believe the Lake Tahoe Visitors Authority chose the original date of the project April 15th. Because of that date Transworld Snowboarding who picked Sierra at Tahoe for this years Super Park decided to relocate to Bachelor. This was a tragedy for the entire basin, Sierra and they’re park crew as well as local professional athletes that could have benefitted from photo shoots etc. This Super Park would have brought people from all over giving the south shore one more little boost before the slow season. I just want to know one thing, why not the fall? We all know, Cal Trans knows and I would assume a contractor with a multi million dollar project with huge bonuses would have done some research into the weather, April and May can be some of the snowiest, rainiest months in the basin.
Once again, I am so disappointed with all the people involved with making major decisions for our community!
I live right below Echo Summit in Christmas Valley and drive up the Summit for work on a regular basis, I have feared avalanches, rock slides, drunk drivers etc. it is a scary pass! Doing it now, verses the fall, does it matter that much, and if we’ve been driving on a road that is at risk of falling down the mountain, shame on Cal Trans, El Dorado County and everyone else involved!
coldrainandsnow- The stated reasoning for not wanting to do it in the fall is the fact that once it starts snowing the snow usually sticks around longer. At least if it snows now it won’t be around long. This was all discussed during city council meetings that were televised about a year ago.
I think it would be beneficial for South Lake Tahoe to delay closure till the day after the event. 4 days shouldn’t hurt anyone and SLT has everything to gain. I’m glad Gaines and others are getting involved to get the May 11th date changed. Any chance these CalTrans guys are benefitting somehow from the North Shore folks? Or are they just idiots disconnected from our community.
It still amazes me how many ignorant people there are on the South Shore. Caltrans, do your work before another car plunges over the clif. This work will not need to be redone for another 50 years, so this closure is a speckle in time. One life is priceless.
Cal Trans was meeting with the south shore representatives over the last 7 months, telling our reps that the discussions were important and that they’d listen to our input. Wrong…the company awarded the contract has the only say, and Cal Trans doesn’t have control over it. This company was the one that rebuilt the bay area overpass in record time (remember the truck ran into it and the fire caused all to collapse?). if they finish ahead of schedule, they get awards of $150,000 for each day, so they want to get it done ASAP and it has to fit into their other scheduled jobs.
If we wait until the following week, would it ruin the traffic for Memorial Day?
Add this to the mixture….Alpine County or Cal-Trans, which ever works on HWY 88, is now beginning to repair all the damage to 88 between Kirkwood and the 89 junction to South Tahoe. Will they be finished by May 11 or will there also be traffic delays due to construction on 88?
Everyone knew about this impending closure 2 years ago. CalTrans has a lot of work to do so just let them do it. The Amgen folks could have gotten this information well in advance, as well as the City and County. People aren’t as stupid as some folks think. If they’re truly interested in getting here they’ll get here, it’s not difficult. Honestly. Just let them do their job.