THIS IS AN ARCHIVE OF LAKE TAHOE NEWS, WHICH WAS OPERATIONAL FROM 2009-2018. IT IS FREELY AVAILABLE FOR RESEARCH. THE WEBSITE IS NO LONGER UPDATED WITH NEW ARTICLES.

Opinion: Calling for an end to cairns


image_pdfimage_print

By Robyn Martin, High Country News

Stones: We’ve built pyramids and castles with them and painstakingly cleared them out of farm fields, using them to build low walls for fencing. We marvel at the rocks in the Grand Canyon, Arches and Grand Teton national parks. Yet a perplexing practice has been gaining ground in our wild spaces: People have begun stacking rocks on top of one another, balancing them carefully and doing this for unknown reasons, though probably as some kind of personal or “spiritual” statement.

These piles aren’t true cairns, the official term for deliberately stacked rocks. From middle Gaelic, the word means “mound of stones built as a memorial or landmark.” There are plenty of those in Celtic territories, that’s for sure, as well as in other cultures; indigenous peoples in the United States often used cairns to cover and bury their dead. Those of us who like to hike through wilderness areas are glad to see the occasional cairn, as long as it’s indicating the right way to go at critical junctions in the backcountry.

Stone piles have their uses, but the many rock stacks that I’m seeing on our public lands are increasingly problematic. First, if they’re set in a random place, they can lead an unsuspecting hiker into trouble, away from the trail and into a potentially dangerous place. Second, we go to wilderness to remove ourselves from the human saturation of our lives, not to see mementoes from other people’s lives.

Read the whole story

image_pdfimage_print

About author

This article was written by admin

Comments

Comments (6)
  1. dumbfounded says - Posted: July 19, 2015

    Don’t we need a few studies before jumping to conclusions? I mean, what are the socio-economic impacts of doing away with cairns? What will the ecological impacts be? How can the USFS create cairn-free zones to protect the habitat? What will the TRPA’s position be? Will the League to Pave Lake Tahoe sue? What about the rocks’ rights to free assembly? What about rock on rock marriage? There are entirely too many questions to answer before we stop building cairns…

  2. Hmmm... says - Posted: July 19, 2015

    @Dumbfounded…are the rocks being adequately compensated for their labor? are there regulations against Cairning while stoned? What about mineral rights? Can I do it while driving?
    Does Global Cairning even exist and if it does what is the role that humans play in it’s formation? Can we mention it in textbooks? Are ‘People for the Ethical Treatment of Cairns going to get involved? Will Ann Bryant form the Cairn League to advise people what to do and not do should a nuisance Cairn be spotted in their neighborhood? Or will Anita Bryant be speaking out against the aforementioned rock on rock marriage? If i feel threatened by one while I’m out walking can I knock it down?

    What does the U.S. Constitution say? Please, talus more.

  3. worldcycle says - Posted: July 19, 2015

    Hahahaha

  4. Hikerchick says - Posted: July 20, 2015

    I agree completely with the statements in the article. Random cairns can mislead a hiker and leave a hiker with a feeling that there is no place that hasn’t been disturbed by humans.

  5. Whip says - Posted: July 20, 2015

    Cairns, really? Hiking and packing for forty years and never heard the three rock stacks we call ‘ducks’ referred to as cairns. Never built one, never used one for direction, never really bothered me, guess I was too busy enjoying my surroundings.
    Pretty sure humans have been stacking rocks since, well, the stone age.
    Opinion: Calling for an end to whining…

  6. nature bats last says - Posted: July 22, 2015

    So stacked rocks take away from the wilderness experience but constant flyovers by sightseeing helicopters are ok? How about dogs running loose all over the forest? And dont forget the trash and toilet trails (tp hanging off bushes). Stacked rocks are really the least intrusive of human presence that I can think of, with the exception of just staying out all together.