Fine sediment clouds future of Washoe Meadow State Park
By Kathryn Reed
MEYERS — “Parklands are for the entire state, not just one community.”
That was the overriding message of Pam Armas, superintendent of the Sierra District of the California State Parks. She was one of many park officials dressed in their trademark green uniforms at Thursday night’s open house at Lake Tahoe Golf Course.
The golf course in Meyers sits on land that is part of the Lake Valley State Recreation Area, adjacent to the Washoe Meadow State Park. Both are part of the State Park system. Many people, even locals, don’t know this is one of the 17 parks in the Sierra District. It made the news in 2007 when nearly 20 acres of the more than 700-acre park burned in the Angora Fire.
America Golf is the concessionaire of the golf course and will continue to have a month-to-month contract until a decision is made about the future of the links, the park and the river that runs through it.
This undeveloped park is ideal for snowshoeing and cross country skiing in the winter, hiking and mountain biking in drier conditions. The old Celio dairy barn is an iconic relic of days gone by.
Trails traverse alongside and across the meandering Upper Truckee River.
A mix of meadows and forest dot the landscape.
Snowmobiling is the most common issue Brian Barton and other park law officials handle. It’s not allowed in the park. In the summer it’s dogs – especially ones off leash. They are only allowed on drivable roads.
Maria Mircheva, executive director of the Sugar Pine Foundation, was dispensing information about blister rust and how it affects the sugar, white bark and Western white pines in the Lake Tahoe Basin.
“We donate sugar pines to the State Parks and they plant it in the upland areas where they see fit,” Mircheva said. “We brought them two boxes (tonight).”
El Dorado County had a table set up to talk about issues such as the Sawmill Bike Path that will go through Washoe Meadow State Park property.
Earth Day was an opportunity for the parks department to showcase Washoe Meadow, to answer questions about animal habitat, plants, forest fuels management, blister rust, law enforcement issues, and re-routing the Upper Truckee River.
Like most reaches of the Upper Truckee River, the one in the park is being studied to potentially re-route it so it would follow its natural path. The draft EIR and EIS should be out this summer. It will include five alternatives. A 60-day comment period will follow. Park officials did not give a time line for when the final documents would be released.
The reason to mess with the river is to reduce the amount of fine sediment that reaches Lake Tahoe. The theory is stream restoration also allows for better plant management, flooding into meadows and other environmental benefits.
But what has people like Krissi Russell, who is part of the Washoe Meadows Community, concerned it the potential relocation of some of the holes from the golf course into the undeveloped area of the park.
This grass-roots organization of 200 people formed in 2006. Mostly it’s people who live in the area or use the park. She said her group also is worried about the logging going on in the park.
Piles of felled trees are sitting in the park waiting to be hauled off when the ground is dry.
“I wonder if the logging is to prepare to move the golf course,” Russell said. “It will fragment the park.”
Her group has made several Public Records Act requests to Armas’ office. The superintendent, after the last request, invited representatives of the group to Tahoe City to look at whatever documents they want.
Armas said she is trying to be as transparent as possible and keep communication open with the public.
Rich Adams, a forester with State Parks, said the goal of his department is to return the area to pre-settlement conditions. This has necessitated removing trees that are more than 100 years old.
He said the problem is fire suppression has created an unnatural environment. Removing trees by hand and machine is being done, as is chipping the material, burning slash piles, having contractors haul away the lumber and having prescribed fires. Some material is sold as lumber, some to cogeneration plants, some to composting companies.
“We want a variety of vegetation structures,” Adams said. “We think having a variety of structure is good for wildlife.”
This means larger trees will be 30-feet apart, while some stands will be more dense.
Lisa Fields, environmental scientist with State Parks, said, “Anything living in this park is comfortable with people.”
This is because the park is surrounded by development.
The golf course is an Audubon certified course – which means it provides substantial bird habitat.
Fields said a study from the state Department of Fish & Game and Caltrans came out this month saying most animals travel around the valley the park is situated in by migrating via the nearby ridges.
Click here for more information about the Upper Truckee River restoration project.
For the record,
the old barn noted as the “Amacker barn” was built in approx. 1916 by the Celio family and was the “dairy barn” for the dairy operation for many years.
Washoe State Park was part of the Meyers holding owned by the Celio family from 1903 to the early 1940 when the 700 acres were sold to the Broder family, cattle rancher from Folsom. Mr. Broder died in the early 1960’s and the family was unable to pay the state inheritance taxes, so the state took the property as payment.
Only Shirley would know the real story about the barn.
Don’t mess with the river… The thought of a project of this magnitude and cost reducing fine sediment is only a theory. The TMDL for Lake Tahoe has calculated that only 4% of the loss of Lake Tahoe’s clarity is coming from streambank erosion. To move this area of the river into a new location, subjecting it erosion again, then forcing it to restabilize will have temporary impacts that will far outway any benefits. This includes both temporary erosion from channel construction to future stabilization I am sure some issues could be fixed without complete geomorphic configuration. These are not water quality projects. Money for these river projects are taking away financial resources from the main impact on lake clarity, “urban stormwater”. State Parks has done some great projects, but this project is waste of time and money in my opinion and could do more harm than good. Give these resources to fixing roads and construct true water quality improvement projects that will have direct impacts on lake clarity.