44-month sentence for S. Tahoe woman in hit-and-run DUI
By Kathryn Reed
“We are here today because two lives were destroyed, but only one by choice,” El Dorado County Assistant District Attorney Hans Uthe told the court Wednesday.
The lives are those of Christine Whalen, who chose to drive drunk, and Adam Rose, who was was hit from behind as he rode his bike on Emerald Bay Road.
That bike, now crumpled, rested against a railing just feet from the man who was riding it before it got in that condition.
He may never ride any bike again. For now, he is using crutches to get around.
The woman whose vehicle crushed the bike and did even more damage to the rider sat with her head down throughout much of Wednesday’s hourlong sentencing hearing.
Whalen was driving on Highway 89 near 12th Street in South Lake Tahoe on Aug. 21 when her vehicle struck Rose, who was on his bicycle.
Whalen, 54, of South Lake Tahoe was sentenced to three years, eight months in state prison for felony hit-and-run with injury, felony driving under the influence and causing injury, and felony failure to yield with the intent to evade. She had a blood alcohol level of 0.23 – nearly three times the legal limit.
Having spent 163 days in El Dorado County Jail and being given the same amount of days for good behavior, Whalen has served nearly one year of her term.
The probation department had sought one full year in county jail. The defense wanted her to be sentenced to the local jail, too. The assistant district attorney said based on the gravity of the situation state prison was the best answer.
“I thought it should have been more,” Rose told Lake Tahoe News of the sentence. “But I don’t know if she had more time, what it would do.”
Several people spoke on Whalen’s behalf, including her daughter who is eight months pregnant. They understood the need for Whalen to be behind bars, but preferred it would be a shorter sentence, and one in county jail.
A restitution hearing is scheduled for March 4. Whalen will be in the county jail until then, so it is possible her grandson will be born in that time.
Rose, 38, was forthright in his testimony to the court on Jan. 30, even saying how he has forgiven Whalen despite the fact his life is nothing like it was and never will be based on his injuries.
“Upon impact you continued down the road 100 feet with me on your hood,” Rose said to Whalen. She made a turn, he flew off the hood onto the ground, skidding for about 50 feet, as his skin was ripped off.
“You left me for dead on the side of the road. While you were running, I was dying.”
Rose went through the litany of injuries he sustained and what his life is like today.
He reiterated to LTN how he is keeping a positive attitude – just like he said in an article published earlier this month.
Prior to rendering the sentence, El Dorado County Superior Court Judge Suzanne Kingsbury said this was probably the worse DUI incident she had seen in her 17 years on the bench.
Kingsbury agreed to recommend alcohol treatment for Whalen, adding that based on the blood alcohol level she doubted this was the first time Whalen had drunk to such excess. However, this is Whalen’s first conviction.
A slap on the wrist. Who runs this town? Justice is NOT being served around here. The worst DUI case in Kingsbury’s career merits 44 months?
Wishing Mr. Rose all my very best in recovery.
toughen up, I kind of agree, but as an avid cyclist myself, I understand Adam Rose’s sentiment that he kind of thought more made sense, but in the end, not sure what it would have accomplished.
It seems to me she is an alcoholic and is not likely to change her behavior, so more at least protects those of us who enjoy riding the roads.
But I struggle with this, then how much is enough? 10 years, 20? I must admit I am not sure.
Rick
This is not a Tahoe thing but a legal system thing. My best friend’s son was killed by a drunk driver in So. Cal 7 yeras ago while skate boarding on a beach sidewalk…the driver guy was partying with his friends and ran a red light and jumped the curb. You know what they guy got for killing him? 19 months!
The maximum sentence available under the law for the crimes Ms. Whalen plead guilty to was four years, four months. Ten or twenty years would not have been a sentencing option for the court in this situation.
@ 30 year local… we share a friend. Thank you for bringing that up, it highlights the very essence of the topic at hand. Considering “she” is your best friend, we most certainly must know eachother, ’cause she is a very close and loved friend of mine as well. hard to believe it’s been 7 years already now.
very sorry for mr rose also however giving this women 20 years in prison doesn’t serve him very well either. She has already lost her career and would not be able to work ever again especially if in prison.
Thanks scadmin for the info.
Rick
I am Adam Rose’s mother. I had hoped that Ms. Whalen would receive the maximum sentence allowed by the court. I wish she was not given credit for time served based on “good behavior”. I understand her family’s desire for her to have a shorter sentence and to serve it in county jail. However, my son has no choice in the life sentence he has to serve. He is getting no “time off” for good behavior. Adam has displayed remarkable character under the most trying of circumstances. His grace and forgiveness to Ms. Whalen serve as an example to all of us. I, too, have prayed for Ms. Whalen since the accident, as well as for her family, and hope she gets the help she needs so that no one else will have to go through what our son and his loved ones have gone through these past several months because of the selfish actions of this woman.
The sentencing statutes enacted by the Legislature require the court, when imposing a sentence, to give a defendant credit for the actual time served plus, in this case, an equal number of “conduct” credits. It happens in every case. In some instances “conduct” credits are limited to a lesser percentage, but that wouldn’t be applicable to this case.
Why is it not mentioned the establishment that over served this woman alcohol and the bartender that over served her or was this a common occurance